The case involves a terminally ill cancer patient with a profoundly. Understanding the principles and applying them in basic concept can help cms participate in conflict resolution or appropriate referrals to ethics committees. We discuss the idea and present two case studies to. The care providers evaluated the case as a matter of maternal autonomy and. Case studies are an important tool in bioethics, especially in practical bioethics where the focus is on real issues in real life and real time. Jay would require aggressive care in an intensive care unit.
Tarris rosell, phd, dmin rosemary flanigan chair at the center for practical bioethics. Medical ethics is founded on a set of core principles. Medical ethics the case scenario in question verily presents a mind boggling situation. Mar 18, 2011 genomewide association studies gwas provide a powerful means of identifying genetic variants that play a role in common diseases.
Some cases have been remarkable for starting broad discussion and for setting precedent in medical ethics. The value of autonomy in medical ethics springerlink. These principles have been popularized by ethics scholars tom beauchamp and james childress in their book principles of biomedical ethics 2009. Importance of medical ethics for medical students world health. She is refusing treatment because she is scared of the treatment which she believes is invasive. The authors discuss ethical issues concerning electronic patient privacy. Some details have been changed to preserve patient privacy. Medical ethics simple english wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Ethical choices is a concise guide to clinical action. The ethics of the relationship between physicians and patients has been explored since the establishment of the hippocratic oath in the 4 th century bc.
Oct 11, 2006 since autonomy is so widely valued, it is clear that the burden of proof here is on the side that wants to reject the view that autonomy has intrinsic value. During my senior year at santa clara, i led discussions on medical ethics with students interested in medicine. Another driver, elderly and distracted by an incoming text message, ran a red light and tboned janet and jacks. Jay attempting resuscitation following a pulmonary arrest was not likely to succeed. A traditional approach to the four principles might view the standard jehovahs witness case as a prominent example of a conflict of ethical principles. Ethical issues addressed in clinical and medical ethics include the right of conscience for healthcare professionals, the role of the professional in decisionmaking, patient autonomy, and informed consent particularly as they find expression. How much authority should an ethics program within a hospital be afforded. Patient autonomy the patientphysician relationship is. Ethical dilemmas in healthcarecase studies and lessons. Berg says the best hope in a case like cassandras is that her. Health care industry health, general duty of care law standards medical ethics case studies. I was also a premedical student, and am currently attending the loyola university chicago stritch school of medicine. Imaging studies of the head showed several areas of hemorrhage.
Nov 17, 2014 principles of medical ethics autonomy beneficence nonmaleficence social justice 4. Hussein doctoral researcher, university of birmingham, former assistant professor, faculty of medicine king fahad medical city, king saud bin abdulaziz university for health sciences email. During the 1960s and 1970s, it became the subject of increasing public concern and debate, culminating in the us with congressional hearings. The scope of practice section of the code asserts that case management is guided by five ethical principles 2015, p. Medical malpractice case studies and best practices presenting. In medical ethics respect for autonomy is considered a fundamental principle. It has however been noted that these ethical issues become high in magnitude and extent when public officials are involved. Throughout the book you will find practical and relevant case studies and examples of best practice in real world situations illustrating common ethical and legal problems and advice on how best to manage them. In addition, the inconsistency between his previous verbal statements and his current behavioral clues raise additional issues about the role of autonomy. Per chart notes, he is not improving sufficiently to warrant hope for.
Bioethics cases markkula center for applied ethics. Through this lesson, you will learn how to define autonomy and gain insight into how the concept works in personal, political, and medical contexts. As a principle that can be readily turned into a process, the giving of informed consent by a patient has become the surrogate measure of whether medical interventions are ethically acceptable. We integrate the results from the analysis using four principles of biomedical ethics into care ethics perspective on triage and propose an integrated clinically and ethically based framework of emergency department triage planning, as seen from a comprehensive ethics.
Although previous work indicates that courses in bioethics have a demonstrable effect on medical students, it has not examined their effect on health care professionals. As it is based on a real case, some details have been changed in the effort to maintain patient confidentiality. Should the american system allow a europeantrained physician to address euthanasia for the purpose of organ donation. In this report, we describe a study designed to investigate the effect of bioethics education on health care professionals. This case illustrates the deficiencies of autonomy as an answer to all questions in ethics. Ethics case study providing care to undocumented immigrants susan coyle, phd, for the ethics and human rights committee. Ethics case study providing care to undocumented immigrants. Essay case study on medical ethics medical ethics is a system of moral principles that apply values and judgments to the practice of clinical medicine and in scientific research. In a theory of medical ethics 1981, he argues that current medical codes such as the hippocratic oath are too restrictive and lack sufficient support for comprehensive use in the medical profession. Promoting autonomy, which they more or less equate with selfdetermination, is good because it enhances wellbeing, maximizes the likelihood of the young person being the main decisionmaker about. This volume offers new and innovative work by joel. These ideas tell doctors how they should treat patients.
With the help of our essaysoft essay software, medical ethics case studies autonomy your will be able to complete your school essays without worrying about deadlines medical ethics case studies autonomy. Feb 26, 20 teaching medical ethics for undergraduate medical students by nonspecialized staff ahfad university for women 14 february 2015 ghaiath m. Jan 12, 2015 exploring the ethics the legal barrier to respecting cassandras autonomy remains, but the ethics of the case are murky. Wall, md, phd singleprocedure interventions with minimal followup and clear qualityoflife gain are well suited for surgical mission trips. Medicaid is also a program that is designed to help fund health care for those. Typically, these studies most based on actual medical casessummarize. As the political, regulatory and best practice landscape is always evolving, we publish updates to the different chapters of the book. Ethical dilemmas concerning autonomy when persons with. However, although autonomy is a central value in western medicine and medical ethics, as i said above, exactly what role it should have in medicine is not clear. These are fundamental and deserve your closest attention. Limited understanding of disease etiology often leads to resistance, which can result in low vaccine uptake.
Case studies provide a roadmap for decisionmaking in. The ethical dilemma in the case discussed below involved whether or not to continue treating a client who clearly needed occupational therapy services based on medical necessity, yet the payersource medicare coverage criteria for services to be delivered at home was questionable. Dec 05, 2014 participatory medicine supports a patients entire autonomy and selfcare and always has. An american mother no longer wishes to care for her handicapped child. Psychosurgery also called neurosurgery for mental disorder has a long history. Case sparks debate about teen decision making in health us news. Please join the thousands of people following us on facebook to stay connected to each months free educational materials. Cassandras autonomy remains, but the ethics of the case are murky. Teaching medical ethics for undergraduate medical students. Some of the principles of medical ethics have been in use for centuries. Case studies case study 2 a competent patient refuses treatment.
He has worked both to assemble numerous case studies and to advance general theoretical reflection in these areas. Participatory medicine may at the moment focus on the doctorpatient relationship in many of its current forms, but that doesnt mean it excludes or discriminates against other forms of health care including selfcare. Medical ethics case study introduction professionals in every field are always confronted with some kind of ethical issues. Respect for patient autonomy trumps beneficence and nonmaleficence.
Medical ethics is the set of ethical rules that doctors follow. In a prima facie sense, we ought always to respect the autonomy of the patient. That is, it focuses on acting morally based on ones duty. The earliest set of ethical ideas in medicine was the hippocratic oath. The case involves a terminally ill cancer patient with a profoundly diminished quality of life and an extremely poor prognosis. College essays are even more challenging to write than high school ones, and students often get medical ethics case studies autonomy assigned a lot of them. To my surprise, i found only one paper in a mental health nursing journal. Explain the process of ensuring patient autonomy while informing. In this case, a physician is legally permitted to notify only a public health official. A selection of medical ethics cases designed to help determine whether medicine is the correct calling for premedical students. Alaska association of medical staff services anchorage, alaska ethical dilemmas in healthcarecase studies and. However, a number of events since 1914 have illustrated how the autonomy of patients may be overridden. It emphasises that one must act in accordance with rules and principles of ethics such as respect for autonomy, nonmalfeasance, beneficence, justice, fidelity, veracity and avoidance of killing. The paper dissects ethical case studies, which students in nursing and medical school often encounter in classes.
More than 50 case studies match ethics concepts to real world situations. Autonomy is a skill that must be encouraged, developed and maintained. Vaping has been thought to be a safe, effective smoking cessation aid, but little evidence supports its value in mitigating tobacco use. Rethinking autonomy and consent in healthcare ethics. The principles of medical ethics involve morals and values that people and healthcare professionals need to take into consideration in case of any conflict or any confusion. I cannot think of another anthology quite like this. One of your senior partners who has been an invaluable mentor he hired you originally, colleague, and friend. Cases journal of ethics american medical association. In the medical context, that means allowing people to refuse medical treatment, even. Medical ethics case study essay 1948 words 8 pages. Unethical treatment leads to lawsuit and dental board action. Ethical principles and the case manager ccmcs case. Jul 18, 2018 the ethical argument, supported by government policy, empirical studies, ethics literature and their own experiences, can be understood as follows. In the book clinical ethics, jonsen and colleagues observe that ethical issues are.
The aim was to describe ethical dilemmas concerning autonomy. Vulnerability, autonomy, and applied ethics brings together theorists working on conceptualizing vulnerability as an actionguiding principle in these discussions, as well as bioethicists, medical ethicists and public policy theorists working on instances of vulnerability in specific contexts. From journalism to performing arts to foreign policy to scientific research to social work, these cases explore a range of current and historic ethical dilemmas, their motivating biases, and their consequences. The doctor further explained that even if resuscitation restarted his lungs, mr. A software platform to analyse the ethical issues of electronic patient. Autonomy essentially means self rule, and it is a patients most basic right. Complex medical situations and care issues can lead to conflicts. Perry not his real name was 83 years old and had several medical problems. Case studies on clinical ethics issues and patient care issues, such as influenza vaccine shortage, longdistance cancer treatment, and conscientious. Medical malpractice case studies and best practices presenting medical ethics issues in physicianpatient encounters, plus the four basic principles of medical ethics. Ethical case study of sarah 1 ethical case study of sarah brittany carriero bridgewater state university introduction. From journalism to performing arts to foreign policy to scientific research to social work, these cases explore a range of.
If this were a oneshot treatmentperhaps painful or uncomfortable but over quicklyit would be easy to conclude that forced medical. Ethics is something that is an unavoidable topic that. When the daughter arrived at the hospital, the patient and daughter were able to converse, and the patient then. Exploring the ethics the legal barrier to respecting cassandras autonomy remains, but the ethics of the case are murky. American college of physicians ethics case studies. Applying the four principles journal of medical ethics. I was a hackworth fellow for the markkula center for applied ethics at santa clara university. Case study by journal of the new york state nurses association. The ethical dilemma of forced chemotherapy on a teen. Medical ethics bioethics case study analysis assig. Ethical dilemmas in healthcarecase studies and lessons learned. Joe is a 62 year old building contractor who has been in an icu for the past 10 weeks. But not all risks and benefits are easily assessed. This column presents a problematic case that poses a medicalethical dilemma for patients, families, and healthcare professionals.
Patients may declare themselves organ and tissue donors prior to death e. It was supposed to be written by hippocrates but probably was not written by him. Each of its case studies on clinical ethics, research ethics, and professionalism issues, all developed by the ethics and human rights committee of the american college of physicians, presents an ethical dilemma relevant to daily practice, considers the possible responses of the physician and the motivations behind them, and elucidates the. Knowledge of basic ethical principles and core concepts may be a useful tool. In this study the ethical dilemmas in each case were intrinsically connected to the specific context and needed to be understood in their entirety. We update our case studies and educational resources regularly. The four quadrants approach to clinical ethics case. It is not clear what this patients wishes are or were. Bell 1927, justice oliver wendell holmes wrote that the involuntary sterilization. Hippocratic oath i will prescribe regimen for the good of my patients according to my ability and judgment and never do no harm to anyone 5.
The goal of this column is to address ethical dilemmas. Discuss the legal and regulatory requirements for medical assistance in dying maid identify and evaluate the personal, professional, institutional, and social values that are relevant to the provision of. However, at times this can be difficult because it can conflict with the paternalistic attitude of many health care. Ethical controversy erupts over minors autonomy 201503. This case study considers the clinical ethics issues of medical appropriateness and quality of life for patients who are critically ill. Medical ethics is a system of moral principles that apply values to the practice of clinical medicine and in scientific research. This case established the principle of informed consent and has become central to modern medical practice ethics. Principles of medical law and ethics knowledge for medical.
A selection of medical ethics cases designed to help determine whether medicine. Ethical issues addressed in clinical and medical ethics include the right of conscience for healthcare professionals, the role of the professional in decisionmaking, patient autonomy. If this were a oneshot treatmentperhaps painful or uncomfortable but over quicklyit would be easy to conclude that forced medical treatment would do more good than harm. An increasing number of gwas is taking place in lower income countries and there is a pressing need to identify the particular ethical challenges arising in such contexts. Educational efforts in bioethics are prevalent, but little is known about their efficacy. She has been counselled about the nature of the treatment there are no alternatives that would be of practical benefit. Humans are a mean unto themselves and not a means to an end.
A case study demonstrates an ethical dilemma faced by healthcare providers who care for and treat jehovahs witnesses who are placed in a critical situation due to medical lifethreatening situations. Patient autonomy and the freedom to act against oness selfinterest a 16 year old hodgkin lymphoma patient refuses to have his blood specimen drawn, thus canceling his scheduled oncologic treatment. Executive summary the connecticut case of cassandra c, a 17year old girl ordered by the state supreme court to undergo chemotherapy against her will, spotlights conflict between respecting minors autonomy and obligations to promote their best interests. But even if you didnt medical ethics case studies autonomy do a lot of essay writing in high school, this doesnt mean youll be medical ethics case studies autonomy so lucky in college.
Vulnerability, autonomy, and applied ethics 1st edition. Jan 22, 2015 case sparks debate about teen decision making in health. These values include the respect for autonomy, nonmaleficence, beneficence, and justice. That is, it focuses on acting morally based on ones duty versus basing ones action on the results that it causes. Medical ethics is based on a set of values that professionals can refer to in the case of any confusion or conflict. Reflections for the physician posted on 102 by george theodore, phd qp, a 47yearold scandinavian woman, visits her primary care physician pcp complaining of abdominal pain.
The following consultation report is based on a real clinical dilemma that led to a request for an ethics consultation. Find case studies on topics in health care and biotechnology ethics, including endoflife care, clinical ethics, pandemics, culturally competent care, vulnerable patient populations, and other topics in bioethics. In healthcare ethics, autonomy has arguably become the principal principle. This case could set a precedent for requiring minors to prove sufficient maturity to make medical.
1575 1378 1381 526 359 970 438 948 1501 1200 1282 360 113 1510 1041 1288 973 1202 1526 1458 969 1200 303 698 375 737 990 616 1254 531